Is Email Work?
A long time ago, I read Cal Newport’s book titled A World Without Email. The recent Outlook outage that took down email services worldwide made me think about it. Is email work? Is it your job? Both, or neither?
I have a love-hate relationship with email. On one hand, it is as pure as communication gets. It lets me reach blogs, people reach me there, I read it whenever I want, I keep it or not, I reply, or I don’t. There are no metrics and no algorithm, and no need to react (unless you use Gmail’s reactions…). It’s direct, nearly instant, and personal.
On the other hand, people use it like a chat app, it is abused, and businesses, especially here in Japan, use it to ping you with nonsense constantly. With no
respect for the sanctity of the mailbox.
At work, it’s probably our most important tool for talking across companies, and that’s where it breaks down. Plenty of people can’t turn their thinking into a clear request or question. We all assume we know how to write email, but do we? I once got one with two paragraphs in the subject line and nothing in the body.
That makes me wonder whether communication is “work” at all, or whether we turn it into work because we’re bad at it.
My work has two main kinds of output. Material, like documents, drafts, sheets, labels. And the immaterial kind, mostly decisions: who gets a task, how to proceed, who to talk to. None of that is an email. An email might carry it, but it isn’t it. So if email goes down, can I still work? I can still draft, design, write, think, and even pick up the phone if an important decision needs to be made, discussed, or transmitted.
My half-baked answer is that email isn’t work. It's how work travels.